The Front Door

We want to add a little curb appeal to the front of our house. 

We are really struggling on which direction to take.

We have two looks that we are interested in.  We're not sure what will complement the Austin white limestone best. 

We either like the door painted black with a cream trim that matches the stone with exterior shutters painted black.

or

The front door painted charcoal with slate trim.  In this case the shutters would be painted charcoal.

Here's an example of the second look.

Which direction should we go?

Please let me here your suggestions.

Thanks for stopping by!